Tuesday, January 20, 2015

Nance O'Neil

I forget how exactly I came across Nance's name, but I think it was when I was reading about Lizzie Borden. 

Yes. THAT Lizzie Borden.

Keep reading to see the connection between these two ladies!

Nance O'Neil was born Gertrude Lamson on October 8, 1874 in Oakland, California. She was the second child born to George, an auctioneer, and his wife, Arre. Her sister, Lillian was born four years earlier. 

George Lamson was a very religious man who publicly denounced his daughter's choice to become an actress. I am not sure if they reconciled before his death in 1903, but I am guessing not. 

Older sister, Lillian also worked as a stage actress. She was married to actor William Desmond, but I am not sure what year they wed. In 1910, she injured her leg in a fall and was left an invalid. She passed away in 1917, possibly due to her earlier injury. I am not sure why George Lamson had such an issue with his youngest daughter's career choice and didn't seem to have a problem with his eldest daughter acting on stage. 

Nance made a big splash on stage and was christened the "American Bernhardt." And it wasn't just in the U.S. where she was a big deal, she also made a name for herself in Australia and Europe. The most notable productions she appeared in include Camille, Hedda Gabler, and Macbeth

Nance made her film debut in 1913's The Count of Monte Cristo. 

Now, at 40 years old, Nance couldn't just swoop in to the budding industry and become competition for Mary Pickford or Theda Bara, but her film career was nothing to sneer at. She actually appeared in some pretty noteworthy films:

  • Appeared in the Seven Deadly Sins serials with Shirley Mason.
  • Appeared in His Glorious Night (1929) with John Gilbert. This is the film that reportedly helped bring about the end of Gilbert's career, due to the interference of L.B. Mayer himself. According to Hollywood lore, L.B. Mayer had Gilbert's voice tampered with so that it was higher than normal. So, audiences saw this dashing and manly John Gilbert on the screen but heard a high, feminine voice come out of his mouth. This is according to legend, mind you. In truth, Gilbert's voice sounded fine. The issue with the performance was more along the lines of bad dialogue and bad direction. Just setting the record straight!
  • Appeared with Renee Adoree in her last film, Call of the Flesh (1930). Renee began to suffer frequently during filming, and the production was almost shutdown completely due to her being sick. She managed to complete the film but sadly she passed away from tuberculosis three years later.
  • Appeared in 1930's The Rogue Song, the only Laurel and Hardy film that is lost. All that remains of the film are the soundtrack and a badly deteriorated technicolor clip.
Her final film appearance was in 1932's False Faces

Nance O'Neil passed away on February 7, 1965 in Englewood, New Jersey. 

She was interred at Forest Lawn in Glendale, California.

Nance was married once, to actor Alfred Hickman. The couple was married from 1916 until his death in 1931. I don't believe they ever had children. 

Now! On to the Nance and Lizzie Borden connection. Nance met the infamous "murdereress" in 1904 while she was performing in Boston. Lizzie was reportedly a big fan of Nance's and was very excited not only to see her perform live, but to meet her as well! The two hit it off and even lived together for a time, throwing lavish parties. There were rumors that the two were lovers, but I haven't found any information to support this. Lizzie idolized Nance and apparently used to follow in her wake because she just adored her. So, perhaps people are assuming that means that there was romantic feelings involved, but again, not enough evidence for me. 

"It's youth that wins hearts!" ~~ Nance O'Neil


  1. She is one pretty lady. As soon as 2 people from the same sex begin a friendship and move in they have to be instantly gay. Unless they have more proof then it is just 2 friends although in this case I would not have wanted to go to sleep with Lizzie in the house

    1. I know, it is ridiculous! Same thing if a man of that time never married, he must have been gay!

      And, yes, I wouldn't want to be sharing a space with Lizzie either lol

  2. Maybe her religious father had issues with her sexual choices but couched it in a denunciation of her choice to be an actress?